Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by detaro 1878 days ago
I don't think the latter part is true, my impression is that the kernel people are very well aware of the limits of their review ability and don't pretend to be unfoolable.
2 comments

There's a wide range of degrees between "unfoolable" and "can be done by a persistent student". I think the impression (at least my impression) used to be is that it was possible before but quite unlikely without state-level efforts, but now we understand a properly advised student can get most of their attempted vulnerabilities inserted.
The pure number of just regular bugs that aren't caught is already a good indicator that not much special effort is needed. (And "just a persistent student" isn't that little, given that the group also contributed regularly to the kernel, was studying its security, ... and thus quite familiar with the field, and the kind of people a nation state would employ for that)
The harder part is probably fooling all of the static analysis tools that get run on the kernel, Coverity, Coccinelle, Smatch, and so forth.