Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by thejsa 1888 days ago
> Why would android even allow such restrictions to be enabled in the first place?

To enforce DRM in streaming apps, mostly; though other apps have ended up bodging that for their own purposes.

I suppose at least in the context of secure messaging or banking apps (which also do this) it makes you think twice before snapping something, but even so I think there should be a variant of whatever API which lets the user override it / disable it globally.

Only genuine security concern I can think of that it addresses is that of screen recording malware / stalkerware (assuming said malware doesn't already have root access on your device to circumvent it...), and perhaps the risk of accidentally screenshotting/capturing something sensitive like bank details while screen sharing.

1 comments

The irony of Android stopping this, and iOS allowing it is not lost on me.
iOS definitely stops it to an extent

you can’t screen record or screenshot netflix or disney+

it doesn’t explicitly block it, but the screen just comes out black or stuck on a single frame

whether that’s a feature or an exploit, I don’t know, but it doesn’t seem too unreasonable

It is blocked on iOS but it's not the app's choice, it has to do with the video player utilizing DRM decoding hardware (Widevine-esque). That's why screenshots can be blocked on Netflix but not on Snapchat.
I was not aware. thank you for the explanation