Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by megous 1884 days ago
Yes, but how showing (shoving) everything under a hamburger menu on desktop helps accessibility? Usually if you back from such a full-page menu, you'll completely leave the website, because it's implemented as some <div> overlay with no one bothering to at least push an entry into history, so it looks like navigation but isn't and is in general very confusing.

On mobile people may be using back button less, but on desktop it's always easily visible and accessible in multiple ways, incl. the keyboard, and at least for me it's almost a reflex to use it. Just ctrl+[ away.

2 comments

Yes, navigation links that don't behave like normal links are also an accessibility problem[1]. That's a separate issue, though; I don't think it is a reasonable argument against supporting reflow based on perceived window size.

[1] https://www.w3.org/WAI/WCAG21/Techniques/failures/F42

Mixing links and dropdowns is a 'well-known' antipattern, in the sense that lots of people don't know not to do it, so everyone is familiar with it once you bring up the subject, but most people don't think about it until someone mentions it.

This is why you see icons in the menu bar indicating that clicking here doesn't navigate you away from the page, but clicking over here instead might send you away from whatever it is you're doing here.

I commonly use it on mobile, it's on the right side at the bottom, a very easy position to reach for my thumb