Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by LogicUpgrade 1904 days ago
Honestly this stands contrary to almost every principle of fair use (transformative work of different character for the purpose of comment, parody etc.).

Google took tons of APIs from a platform and implemented them into... a platform.

If you think designing thousands of classes is not substantial that's a very different argument, different from fair use.

Fair use means yes, APIs are copyrightable, but this is transformative use. And, to anyone with a clue in software dev... no it's not.

It's basically like taking someone else's script as-is and shooting a movie from it, and the court deeming this use of a script "fair use".

1 comments

Is a restaurant menu copyrightable?
Recipes and menu listings are not. The artistic layout of the menu is.

Disclaimer: IANAL

Artistic layout... The formatting?