Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by porphyra 1911 days ago
Tesla fanboys seem to frequently forget the following facts:

* People using lidar also use deep learning.

* Lidar and HD maps are totally orthogonal concepts with nothing to do with each other. Lidar helps you avoid running into trucks without HD maps. Camera-based methods can use HD maps too.

* Lidars are less affected by rain and snow than cameras are (thanks to larger optical aperture, multiple returns, and faster "shutter speed" due to nanosecond pulses rather than 1/30 s exposures).

* Tesla's "big data" is not more effective than a concerted active learning data collection campaign with a moderate-sized fleet.

* HD maps are very cheap to create.

* Lidars may in fact be cheaper than the GPU you're going to need to run your monocular depth network, while being more accurate and more robust.

2 comments

FWIW, you can just buy HD Maps: https://www.tomtom.com/products/hd-map/
> Tesla's "big data" is not more effective than a concerted active learning data collection campaign with a moderate-sized fleet.

Provided any concurrent can build a team of people with as much focus and ressourced as tesla. Even if equal, big data from real drivers beats everything else.