[iso1631]

Dunno how you'd make a 10 byte packet, the smallest valid ethernet packet was 64 bytes, and I'd expect my switch to forward those at line speed just fine, and drop any runt packets just fine too. Maybe you could hack a network driver to deliver some really nasty frames, but that doesn't seem a likely situation for rsyncs use case -- not compared with a switch failure for other means.

The point about QOS is that it often isn't necessary because you shouldn't be hitting those limits, and if you do you often don't care (because you've got half a dozen identical desktop computers talking to an unmanaged network not doing any relevant dscp marking). In rsyncs case the traffic they're sending is all ssh traffic - what's going to be doing the tagging and differentiation?