Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rangewookie 1915 days ago
To be fair - news is not a social media platform. I don't know why every webpage on the internet needs a comments section anyways. News articles can be posted elsewhere for public comment and discussion. Like here or reddit, twitter, etc.
2 comments

Exactly, the OP comment is pretty ridiculous. It's equivalent to demanding the local news TV station put your phone call on air so you can share your uneducated and often off topic opinion on what was just displayed.
There’s value in a discussion being tied to the community of news readers as its own social environment. Twitter and Reddit have heavy, biased moderation that don’t even allow many legitimate viewpoints. Plus you have to deal with their user bases, who are strongly opinionated and would drown out the voices of dedicated followers of a newspaper. Just like any community subset has some value in its separation and identity, there is value in the news comment sections.