Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by zepto 1920 days ago
> As that process occurred, the value of the weapons would spike as scarcity took hold

This seems implausible. The number of guns used in crime is in the tens of thousands each year.

The number of guns sold this year was more than 20,000,000.

The number in circulation is greater than 400,000,000.

Even in Australia compliance with gun buybacks wasn’t much more than 50%, and they didn’t have a second amendment.

The idea that Guns will become scarce in the US any time soon is simply unrealistic.

As for the 10,000 glock, that situation is also just a fantasy.

In London criminals can simply rent guns, fairy cheaply but with a high deposit. They only discard them if they fire them in a crime, otherwise they return them and get their deposit back.

This way, even just one gun can be used by hundreds of criminals at minimal expense, and with little risk of being caught possessing an illegal weapon.

1 comments

One thing is, you have to subtract bolt guns, and bolt gun calibers from circulating firearm and ammunition totals. That should cut the number down quite significantly.

The guns wouldn't instantaneously disappear overnight in this scenario. It would take 10-20 years to see a sizeable impact.

I have an interesting quote related to the UK and gun laws:

Gun deaths remain extremely rare in Britain, and very few people, even police officers, carry firearms. But the growing presence of American weapons on the streets, which has not previously been widely reported, comes as serious violent crime, like murders and stabbings, has risen sharply.

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/08/12/world/europe/handguns-smu...

So, hey, U.S. firearms restrictions might have some very positive outcomes for the U.K. (and Mexico as well).

I'd love if you could share an article about that firearms rental operation, how prevalent those weapons actually are, and if they're coming in from the United States.