Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Shank 1921 days ago
I think there's always some skepticism that should be expressed around wild articles like this.

At a core level, remote work during the COVID-19 pandemic is unlikely to mirror remote work outside of the pandemic. It's one thing if you choose to work remotely and if your company willingly embraces remote work. It's an entirely different beast if your company is forced to transition to remote work while stay-at-home orders keep everyone locked indoors with minimal activities to do outside of work.

The pandemic is challenging for many people, including people like me, who are full time remote workers. It's a poor time to evaluate the productivity differences of remote versus non-remote workers.

This article states:

> Operational improvements — like scientific experiments — shouldn't operate on guesses and hope. In our current mass experiment of remote work, we should form hypotheses, act deliberately, and measure results.

One of the most critical things you must consider when designing an experiment is confounding variables. COVID-19 didn't just shift people to remote work. It created a lot of stress, anxiety, and changed society dramatically in more ways than simply moving people's office locations. It cannot be ignored in judging the efficacy of remote work as a subject.

4 comments

It added some and also removed some of the possible distractions from remote work.

Kids at home for schooling is an addition. Many of the fun activities being closed is a removal. There’s no bar or restaurant to get together with friends, no club/rec level sports to play, etc.

I agree that there are a lot of confounding variables, but think many were pro-efficiency rather than all being detrimental.

> There’s no bar or restaurant to get together with friends, no club/rec level sports to play, etc.

Not having these kinds of things available for long periods of time can cause people who relied upon them for an outlet to become depressed, which almost always hurts productivity

What a strange take. I disagree, I believe people in general will be more unproductive if there’s nothing fun to do.
Having no outlet for socializing or getting a change of scenery is a massively bad thing when you also suddenly find yourself working in your house all day for a lot of people. There might be some personality types that don't mind, but it's driving me bonkers personally.
Absolutely, working from home is only one possible form of the remote work, and probably the most boring one. Working from a park, or a caffe, or a local hub, or some hotel anywhere in the world are all much nicer options, but quite impossible these days.
Children not being in school is another major difference.
Yeah, and however much I enjoyed the opportunity to spend copious amount of time with my son when the kindergartens were shut, it did destroy my capacity as I juggled parental oversight shifts with my wife...