[Ductapemaster]

Ah! What a coincidence — I registered my Banana Republic account with a gmail "+" email (eg, [e-mail]) as is my standard practice with retail accounts, and I have the same login issues. It's quite odd, but I'm glad it's not just me!

[davchana]

Wallethub let me register [e-mail] but did not allow + sign in login. Cant signup again with [e-mail] Had to ask support to fix that.