Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by asoneth 1921 days ago
I'm not sure any of the vegans I know would give up veganism in order to minimize their scars any more than the meat-eaters I know would give up meat based on studies that show it can be mildly unhealthy.
2 comments

Maybe I'm reading into it too much, but the outcome of this study seems to suggest there may be other healing-related issues attached to veganism.
I wouldn't be surprised, though I would be similarly skeptical that other healing-related issues would sway people one way or the other either since (at least the vegans I know) don't adopt the lifestyle for health reasons.

Very large effects are unlikely given the number of long-term vegans who seem to maintain sufficient health. Whereas small effects might be considered a worthwhile sacrifice.

Agreed as a vegetarian, this study being called damning is a joke. Veganism has a pretty good track record with respect to health outcomes. Committed vegans that I know would still do it if it lowered their lifespan, because they are doing it for a higher cause (environmental, moral, spiritual, etc.)
I reject your premise that eating meat makes you “mildly unhealthy”
Exactly.

[To clarify: I am not qualified to judge the general healthiness of any particular diet -- any sufficiently popular diet seems to have conflicting studies showing it is "healthy" and others showing it is "unhealthy". The point I intended to make above was that most people either outright reject or remain unswayed by these kinds of studies.]