Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by WillSlim95 1947 days ago
Hindi as a link language is a non-starter, unless people in North Indian states also learn South Indian languages.

To simply understand this point, forcing exclusive use of Hindi in Central government institutions gives an undue advantage to people from North India.

You mention in principle, but in practice the opposite happens. I am an East Indian who has spent all his life in South India I speak both Hindi and a South Indian language along with my native tongue. When North Indians come to South India, and stay for a long time a majority of them refuse to learn the local language whereas every South Indian who has spent time in the North picks up Hindi.

1 comments

As a tamil myself I do not necessarily expect that, since each South Indian language is very different.

Hindi translates easily to tamil, compared to English. I do not approve of forcing a language, however I do not see it being forced in anyway.

Contrast that with forcing native people to fill bank forms in English, or the fetishization of urudu.

Forcing is unnecessary as people are understanding the utility of hindi.