Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tx 6525 days ago
How do Gnome Apps look like on KDE 4.x? I really dig their improvements, but nearly all applications I use are GTK-based [Firefox, gVim, SqlBrowser]. Do they get the same window look/feel? Font settings? How well are they integrated into KDE desktop overall?
1 comments
jrockway 6525 days ago
How well are they integrated into KDE desktop overall?

Not well. It's sort of like using X11 apps on OS X. Alone, they look great. When inside OS X, they look terrible. Gnome is like that on KDE.

link
tx 6525 days ago
So... what's the point of KDE then? I don't think I've ever seen KDE ports of vim or emacs (only GTK), and FireFox is also GTK... Then there is Gimp, how can you do without it...

The only KDE app that is worth using compared to GTK counterparts that comes to mind is probably Amarok [and I still prefer Rythmobx].

Am I missing something here?

link
kbrust 6523 days ago
There was Kvim for KDE3, now there is a vim-like editor called Yzis which integrates pretty well with the environment. You might also want to take a look at "gtk-qt-engine".

In my experience GTK apps look and work a lot better in the KDE environment then the other way around.

link
jrockway 6525 days ago
emacs and vim are so different from "desktop apps" that you won't notice the difference.

For everything else, most people use the KDE version of whatever app they are looking for. I haven't used any applications other than emacs, urxvt, firefox, and amarok for years, so I can't really tell you what those are.

Edit: actually, I can tell you some things. There are themes that make Firefox look like a KDE app, and of course there is Konqueror (I tried 4.0 for a while, it was much nicer than FF2.) There is also a GIMP equivalent for KDE, but the name escapes me. My advice is to install a KDE 4.1 version of Kubuntu, and click stuff in the menus.

link
tx 6525 days ago
emacs and vim are so different from "desktop apps" that you won't notice the difference.

Well... gVim is pretty nicely integrated into Gnome, picks up theme/colors/icons, etc. I like it a lot.

Thank you for replying BTW: I will definitely install 4.1 myself. If FF and Gimp experience won't suffer, I may actually consider switching.

link