Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ahepp 1953 days ago
To go one level deeper, I feel your comment exhibits a fallacy as well.

Sure, science progresses over time. It's fallacious to say that science is wrong because we used to think the sun revolved around the earth. Evidence evolved, ideas changed.

But dismissing all instances of scientists changing their mind, when they really just lied, as "oh, evidence evolved" is the kind of thing that (I feel) erodes trust in science.

I think the evidence is strong that advice against masks was a lie meant to prevent panic, not honestly communicated "best we could do at the time" science. A lie with good intent for overall public health, but dishonest nonetheless.

1 comments

It did seem like there was a initial misinformation panic statement to try to save ppe for medical staff