Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by machello13 1957 days ago
I've been using this model keyboard for probably around 10 years now. I even have a couple spares sitting in a drawer since they don't make them anymore.

* they're very durable (talking normal usage + spilling drinks a few times a year — no stuck or broken keys)

* the key labels never fade

* there's 2 low-power USB ports (I think USB 2.0?) which aren't good for much, but good enough to plug a mouse into

* it's not the easiest thing to take apart but if you get crumbs under a key, it's pretty easy to pry it up and then click it back in

4 comments

Interesting, a cup of sweet tea killed my A1243. Water got inside and shortened some pads or tracks, since pressing one key instead generated 3 or 4 others. I tried to dry it with rise and silica gel for weeks - didn't help. Then I tried to open it and that was an excellent example of an Apple product which feels great while it works and has 0 repairability, so is an e-waste when broken. Disassembly of any other keyboard would allow to fix such a simple problem. At the end I've got a used A1243 from ebay and am typing on it right now :) (if it breaks I would probably go to Logitech MX keys for Mac).
Yep, a splash of coffee is what finally did mine in and they’re totally unserviceable.

Fortunately low-profile keys have been growing in popularity in the mechanical keyboard community so there are some excellent options to choose from now.

During disassembly what surprised me the most was that the back plate is really rigid, since that plastic is reinforced with a metal plate. Instead of fixing that plastic-metal assembly with excessive use of glue, some 6-10 screws on the perimeter could produce the same solidity feel. Unfortunately much less repair-friendly and probably more expensive solution was used instead.
As a rule, screws are more expensive than glue for manufacturing.
I've been using my desktop with a portable monitor and a lapdesk, due to recent high demand for work-from-home space in my apartment. We shouldn't undervalue those USB ports, it is really nice to have all the non-monitor user interface stuff go through a single wire, if the alternative is to have a bunch of wires tangled around you on the couch.
>talking normal usage + spilling drinks a few times a year

I've definitely dumped at least one cup of tea into mine, possibly even more, and it's still working perfect. It's quite bizarre actually.

I dumped an entire cup of tea into a 2016 MPB, it did not survive as well as your keyboard
My coworker apparently managed to dump at least some tea into his 15-inch MacBook Pro and it actually survived. I found it quite surprising, would've figured it was a death sentence for sure.
Same. Love em. My current one is dying. Are there any similar ones on the market?
I don't know. I have one spare left — when that's gone I'm toast. I think I remember reading something about a logitech keyboard with similar key travel, but that was years ago and I don't remember the model.