Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by cogman10 1957 days ago
Can it be proven that there's not a teapot in the asteroid belt?

Extraordinary claims required extraordinary evidence. A massive rock being hurled to by a supernova to our solar system is far more likely than advanced aliens dumping a ton of future tech to get this huge thing into our solar system for a split second.

Why? Because, it would cost a lot of energy, something I doubt an advanced race would spend. Further, an advanced race that wants to probe us wouldn't need such a huge object, it's far easier to observe from a far (think, james webb telescope but better). Sure, hard to know what aliens are thinking, but it just seems incredibly unlikely they are thinking "Let's build this half mile long space probe for a glimpse of a distant solar system and send it off for a million year journey".

A star exploding and sending a bunch of mass our direction is far more likely. Why? because we know that happens relatively frequently.

2 comments

> it would cost a lot of energy, something I doubt an advanced race would spend.

While I agree with your overall conclusion, I don't see that we have any evidence that as a race progresses technologically, they spend less energy. The opposite seems to be true.