Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dkersten 1975 days ago
My main issue with ORM's is that they encourage you to mix application code and queries (by making it easy and by making the code for both look the same), blurring the boundary between your application and the database.

This is a problem, because there is a real boundary, typically including a network round trip. I've been on way too many projects where ORM-using code would pull some stuff from the database, do some application logic to filter or process the results, then loop and do another query for each result. Instead of doing it in the database query itself using joins (and possibly being able to use indexes for the filtering).

Even when people are very disciplined about this, I find that once you get to non-trivial queries, they become a lot harder to read in ORM code. I tend to have to think in terms of SQL, then translate between that and the ORM code on the fly. Its not so easy.

Sure, you could say all the teams I've ever worked on that did stuff like this are just bad at using ORM's, but after a few experiences like this on different teams, in different companies, with different developers, its time to stop blaming the people and maybe take another look at the tools.

1 comments

I really feel your pain. This is not yours or ORM concept fault.

There is just no good ORMs out there.

Except ActiveRecord (and maybe mongoose for mongo). And even these 2 are not the best choice for all use cases.