Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by PragmaticPulp 1969 days ago
In practice, hobby CNC machines use the closed-loop feedback systems to halt the machine and alert the operator that something has gone wrong.

Hobby-scale machines shouldn’t need closed-loop systems for positioning during cutting operations. Especially if they’re using a 300-400W (sustained) consumer router as their spindle as this article suggests.

Cutting forces at this scale are in the single-digit pounds. Nothing a common NEMA23 can’t handle with plenty of margin. Trying to push a low-powered spindle through the workpiece on a low-rigidity hobby machine causes more problems.