Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by smitty1e 1979 days ago
Which matters more: rational minds, or truth?
3 comments

Obviously both are important, but I would at least thing that approaching an issue from a rational mind (not angry, etc.) would help one arrive at truth much more quickly.
I'm seeing large chunks of "rational" people avert their gaze from consideration of "truth", and the fallout promises to be ugly.
In a democracy, neither. It’s consensus, or at least a critical mass of acquiescence. Rationality or truth haven’t any part in it.
The US isn't a democracy though...
>> Has the free expression of all ideas through current means allowed rational minds to prevail? It seems that the status quo has failed to facilitate rational discussion.

> Which matters more: rational minds, or truth?

That question is based on a false premise. Irrational minds aren't going to arrive at truth through their own processes, except by accident.

And "free expression of all ideas through current means" hasn't allowed the truth to prevail, either. It's allowed even blatant, meritless lies such as QAnon and "Stop the Steal" to become widespread and influential, supported by a whole constellation of other more subtle lies.

> meritless lies such as ..."Stop the Steal"

I sincerely hope to see this election put to a thorough legal test after the inauguration, because I'm falling short of agreement with you here.

>> meritless lies such as ..."Stop the Steal"

> I sincerely hope to see this election put to a thorough legal test after the inauguration, because I'm falling short of agreement with you here.

Why? It was already heavily scrutinized and no problems where found, and certainly none that would change the outcome in any way.

Also, it's clear that the main (perhaps only) reason this election was challenged was to assuage the fragile ego of an insecure man with a gift for demagoguery, a man who apparently has always used "loser" as the ultimate insult and cannot tolerate being one.