Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by egonschiele 1982 days ago
I'm guessing this was submitted because of Twitter's ban of Trump's account, so I'm responding accordingly.

I don't think anyone thinks open internet is a bad thing, or that censorship is a good thing.

I DO think it's up to each of us to figure out which is the lesser evil. Counting this link, the evils up for ranking are:

1. Twitter banning Trump's account.

2. Trump using his account to incite hate.

3. Internet service providers being ordered to block social media and messaging apps.

If I had to rank them from most -> least evil, I'd say 3, 2, 1.

Possibly others here will have a different ranking. But for gods sake lets argue about the ranking and not about whether censorship is bad or not, since that dead horse has been brought to life and beaten to death again.

1 comments

You guessed wrong. I wonder if reading the Tweet before commenting rather than guessing would have saved you from all that rant?

Not that I disagree with your comment, just think tweets are pretty short and far too many comment without reading anything other than the title.

Well I did read the Twitter thread but now I’m curious what I missed.
Ahead of the Ugandan election, we're hearing reports that Internet service providers are being ordered to block social media and messaging apps.

We strongly condemn internet shutdowns – they are hugely harmful, violate basic human rights and the principles of the #OpenInternet.

Ah okay, let me try again with a different top-level comment.
Sorry my bad, I interpreted your comment to mean Twitter "Tweeted" in regards to Trump. I now see that You may have meant, You guessed it was linked to HN because of Trump whuch is entirely plausible. Sorry for the Snark.
Heh, no problem! I have two top level comments now so I guess now I'm A/B testing them to see which is more popular.