Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by danlugo92 1986 days ago
>Who can blame anyone with 'no ties' to Canada moving on for 2x salary?

Does that salary increase make up for the lost gov benefits (free healthcate etc?)

4 comments

It depends on one's situation.

'Gainfully Employed' people are generally better off in the US. The healthcare there is great - when you are covered.

The risk comes for those unfortunate/unforeseen situations, and of course, when one doesn't have coverage.

Overall - it's one of those factors that goes into the equation - but for a young, single talented person, usually it's not a priority - or - it factors favourably.

It's a good point because for the 'elite economy' - US healthcare is just fine. Good in fact.

For the 'everyone economy' it's arguable that Canadian style (or something like that is better).

The H/C equation kind of reinforces what I am saying: exceptionalism vs. the commons + stability.

When the new employer is likely footing 90%+ of the bill (pretty standard in skilled professional jobs) then the answer is a clear yes. 100k CAD = ~$78k. Somebody making 100k CAD is likely commanding 110-120k USD at a minimum in the US. CAD equivalent is 140-153k CAD. Knock off $2k for healthcare out of pocket. Don’t forget the significantly lower tax burden. The worker cones out significantly ahead.
> Don’t forget the significantly lower tax burden

Very dependent on where you work. High tech salaries are concentrated in California, where the tax burden at your numbers will be higher than most provinces. I remember doing a comparison of BC to California, and the cross over point was about $250k USD (where taxes become more favorable in California).

I’m referring to Middle America salaries in most mid sized cities. If those same people went to NYC or SF it would be another story. Likely 2x at least.
Yes. Absolutely. It so much more than makes up for lost government benefits.

Health insurance working for a decent US tech company generally requires some out of pocket, but the amounts are really quite modest. Premiums are typically mostly paid by the employer and not considered part of your compensation. If you're single you'll probably pay nothing for insurance premiums and potentially up to a few thousand out of pocket if you're a heavy user of health care, and maybe $5k in the absolute worst case (and the out of pocket is often tax free). If you've got a family, you might pay a couple thousand per year in premiums and $10k in out of pocket maximum. These numbers are honestly chump change for people who are earning $50k-250k more, with better career prospects and more high paying employers to choose from if a particular job doesn't work out.

Yes, when you're young, healthy, and unencumbered by family. Like anyone who is mobile enough to make the move.

It's like the old bait-and-switch swindle.