Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by erulabs 1985 days ago
Well said! However toxic parlor is, I think there is some danger in painting it as radically right or alt right or whatever term. Someone just has to pull up their homepage and only slightly avoid critical thought to come to the conclusion that freedom of speech and anti-censorship is somehow a radical right wing value - which could not be further from the poli-sci meaning of right/left WRT hierarchies.

> even if it’s 80% right, perpetuating the same lazy thinking (sic) has resulted in a future that is guaranteed to make the future of our kids a major struggle.

That is extraordinarily well put.

1 comments

I didn't really do much with my Parler account.. mostly because engagement isn't really there yet.

I'm personally very free speech oriented, but that ends where the legality of speech ends. Insight to violence, and I think doxing should also be illegal or censored.

I think the problems come in a couple forms. First, the best way to combat bad ideas is to bring them to light, not ridicule, persecution or isolation which will only serve to instill a victim mentality which will sew more problematic outcomes. In the end, the calls to excise those that have differing opinions, views or ever did can only serve to make things worse, not better.

When discourse is no longer an option, violence is largely inevitable. It's when people feel they no longer have a voice that these things happen.

Conspiracy theory or not, when the media, congress and so many just dismissed a huge portion of the population, it was bound to end this way... bouncing Parler off apple and google stores, combined with the cleaning house actions of Facebook and Twitter will only serve to escalate problems, not resolve them.

I don't agree with the violence, I didn't agree with it for the better part of the past year when it was far left activists, I don't agree with it now. The only thing I will say is the contrast in response is a bit hypocritical on a lot of high profile individuals.

> I'm personally very free speech oriented, but that ends where the legality of speech ends. Insight to violence, and I think doxing should also be illegal or censored.

But twitter is full of that, and they even allow it, if the targets are "right" (as in "not wrong").

https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/clarissajanlim/teen-nam...

doxxing (for the "right" reason)

#killallmen tranding on twitter.... and allowed, and in general a lot of violent calls against a few "unprotected groups of people"

I'm not against a striclty moderated social network (="kid safe"), if you treat #killalmen and #killallwomen the same (and all other examples), and marketing it as such. But choosing a side, and removing only the others sides posts, while leaving the ones you agree with up, is a bad thing for everyone.

Sites like reddit might be even worse, where everyone can create a subreddit, and only some get banned ( https://www.reddit.com/r/WatchRedditDie/comments/dtqb29/rfra... ).

I think the MeWe platform is a lot easier for communication between members.