Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by eggie5 1993 days ago
anyone still like classic notebooks better???
2 comments

Yes! Every now and then I give JupyterLab a go but I keep going back to classic notebook. The only two extensions I need is Vim key bindings and Black formatting. I might checkout version 3 in a few months, but classic has a “feel” that just works for me. I’ve also tried the VSCode abs PyCharm notebooks. The dealbreaker is always how it displays the output of cells. It sucks compared to classic.
Then you might be interested in a new project called JupyterLab Classic, an alternative JupyterLab distribution with the Classic Notebook look and feel: https://github.com/jtpio/jupyterlab-classic

Once the vim and black extensions adopt the new extension distribution system, they should also be compatible with JupyterLab Classic.

I do. The find and replace is better. You can do it across multiple cells. I don't like the drag and drop method of moving cells. Switching between notebooks is faster if you normally use multiple large notebooks at the same time. I am biased against JavaScript heavy UI. I just have had so many bad experiences with single page apps. The only problem I have with notebooks is the mathjax J's seems to cause the browser to hang on opening or running large notebooks. But it was the same in labs, but even worse with the tabs being handled by the UI instead of the browser. Switching back and forth between tabs and having to wait for them to render was annoying. I gave it a good go for a while recently, but the find and replace in classic notebooks is just so good I couldn't make the switch permanent.