Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by combatentropy 2002 days ago
But this highlights the difference between the two devices, stopwatches and timers.

A stopwatch counts up. Therefore, it makes sense to use the floor (4.99 is still "4", not yet "5").

A timer counts down. Therefore, it makes sense to use the ceiling (3.01 is still "4", not yet "3").

In fact this was a turning point in the original article: "rounding down . . . makes a lot of sense when counting up. . . . But for a countdown timer, this is counterintuitive."

1 comments

Yup, that was my motivation for rewriting the parent statement. Abstracting away the type of counter and just saying, "show the number only when you crossed it" basically.
Sorry. First, I thought that you set out to contradict, rather than agree with, the person you replied to (since that is common). Then I was thrown off by your topic sentence, which seemed to lump together the two devices ("timers and stopwatches"). At this point, I think my reading accelerated to highway speeds and totally botched parsing the rest ;)