Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by chapel 5508 days ago
It is sad how this has been misrepresented.

First of all, this was an email conversation between Ryan Dahl and Zed Shaw. That you know. What you probably don't know is that Ryan first posted this tweet [0] about rewriting Zed's http parser. Zed then responded twice [1] & [2], vehemently. Ryan then responded with a single "?" to Zed's outbursts. That is when Zed said this: "@ryah And don't make me bust out the fucking email you sent me trying to trick me into giving you a MIT license. I swear I'll trash you." [3] Then shortly after another attack [4]. Ryan then again responded somewhat confused: "@zedshaw http-parser uses nginx's url parser, and your external c api (it's a good api) but it's not a modified ver. of mongrel's http11. ??" [5] After that he offered up the above link with the email conversation Zed alluded to [6].

If you know anything about the http parser, you would know that it was written by Ryan and is no longer an issue. That is why the license was changed, why give attribution to Zed if he didn't write anything? Not to mention after the above outburst.

The title of this post is wrong, misleading, and linkbait.

[0]: https://twitter.com/ryah/status/69557901546631168

[1]: http://twitter.com/zedshaw/status/69583774119239681

[2]: http://twitter.com/zedshaw/status/69584110305284097

[3]: http://twitter.com/zedshaw/status/69584284339544064

[4]: http://twitter.com/zedshaw/status/69618172252274688

[5]: http://twitter.com/ryah/status/69620659650699264

[6]: http://twitter.com/ryah/status/69624489893314560

2 comments

http://bettween.com/ryah/zedshaw/May-07-2011/May-15-2011/asc is far more readable ;)

But back on topic... Even if Ryan really rewritten all of the original mongrel's code by hand, then there is still issue with nginx-based portions. Why there is no attribution to Igor Sysoev?

Yeah, but what is the fun in that?

If it was rewritten, with all new code, why would there need to be attribution?

Ryan said that the current version uses nginx's URL parser, so clearly not everything is new code.
Awesome, that clears that up.
It's funny that Zed threatens to "trash" Ryan, but this conversation really makes him look bad more than anything else.