Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by whyamibothering 2009 days ago
That's not a study. That's an anecdote.

They actually have a lower rate of patient regret than LASIK.

This is a study:

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-014-0300-8

n = 767. Over fifty years. Lower rate of patient regret than LASIK.

Further, sex reassignment surgeries aren't the only treatment, and they aren't even one relevant to the article.

2 comments

You should read the study, their methodology for regret was only to account for people that requested a reversal:

"The regret rate is defined as the number of sex reassigned individuals at the time period when they did their first application that will later apply for reversal to the original sex"

The study also did not account for suicides or being sanctioned in their regret rate.

I have, in fact, read the study; I'm doing my thesis in this area.
What other treatments are there? Do you have a good resource if I'd like to learn more?
Non-surgical medical treatment is generally the most fruitful. (SRS, or GCS, is a surgical procedure involving construction of genitalia, and up until very recently there weren't any decent options for it.)

Unfortunately, therapy alone generally isn't shown to make suicide rates or gender dysphoria go away.

Elsewhere in this thread I posted a link to a great talk that has the leading expert in transgender care go into extreme depth on methods of treatments for transgender patients. If you want a doctor's perspective, and one that has probably the most experience tied to it (he sees an incredible volume of transgender patients), I definitely recommend checking it out.