Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nhojb 2013 days ago
Yeah, I feel the same way about Dash 5. Eventually had to upgrade to 5 when 4 became incompatible with the latest Apple docets. But I much preferred the Dash 4 search.
1 comments

The developer of Dash is very receptive to feedback (in fact I think this change was called out as something that he was interested in hearing opinions on).
That's not my experience. I've reported this to him on two occasions, with screenshots and detailed descriptions of how the UX had regressed.

First one took a year before I got a reply (after reminding him), and only partly answered the request.

The second one I'm still waiting for a reply.

I would love for Dash 5 to fix these issues still, and I would upgrade in a heartbeat, but as it stands, I'm stuck with Dash 4.

The issues are:

1. Dash 4's sidebar shows significantly more hits when searching, making it a lot easier to find what you were looking for, compared to the "omnibar" of Dash 5:

https://i.imgur.com/smuNFws.png vs https://i.imgur.com/SeTShSL.png

2. Dash 4 shows/loads the currently selected search immediately, requiring no extra step. Dash 5 requires the user to press enter to confirm the search. This is especially frustrating when triggering a search from an editor

edit: where did he indicate he was looking for feedback on these features?

> where did he indicate he was looking for feedback on these features?

I thought it was in the release notes for v5, but I can't find them at this point to verify. I suppose I may be misremembering.