Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jtbayly 2018 days ago
The discussion was about manufacturing and whether it was a good idea to bring it back and if so how.

I don’t think your comments have added anything of value to that discussion, just bringing politics in for the sake of mocking.
1 comments
mbesto 2018 days ago
The parent comment mentioned he is a registered republican, so its relevant. I was merely making a joke about that since they referenced that in their comment. They also mentioned:

> the last LCD panel manufacturer in the US closed around then and we could no longer manufacture LCD for our military vehicles

Where did they say it was a good idea or a bad idea? Where did I say it was a bad idea? My reply was commenting specifically on the fact that the party he supports literally tried to manufacture the one item he was referring to and failed at it.

Maybe YOU'RE the one with little value added to this discussion other than getting triggered.

EDIT: Just to clarify - you seem to be only focusing on one part of my comment an interpreting exactly what you want to hear. Maybe take a step back and realize what's important to you.

link
jtbayly 2018 days ago
> Where did they say it was a good idea or a bad idea?

The entire comment made the case. But if you want specifics, how about the sentences immediately prior to the one you pulled out of context: “I argued vociferously to a Dem friend in 2000 that our inability to manufacture critical components was going to kill us. Kind of literally:”

But yeah, I’m sure the problem here is that I’m “triggered.”

link
mbesto 2017 days ago
There's a difference between saying corporate welfare is a bad idea and saying manufacturing in the US is a bad idea. I said the former and you inferred the latter. I criticized the implementation of an idea and you focused on the idea. It's amazing how predictable you lot are.

For the record - manufacturing output in the US is trending upward[0] (sans recession). Manufacturing employment is down, not because it's outsourced to China, but because its being automated.

[0] - https://fredblog.stlouisfed.org/2016/05/manufacturing-up-dow...

link