Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by marshray 2029 days ago
"Entering the country illegally is illegal" is restating the law. Such a statement would likely take on more meaning given the context in which it was said.

"Nobody has the right to ..." is your opinion.

1 comments

Well, "nobody has the legal right to..." is restating. And to me, the "legal" is rather obviously implied.
INAL but it is your right to illegally cross the border of a Geneva convention signatory country and seek an asylum. So no, not the same.
I don't agree the implication is obvious at all. Interpreting it that way make it a total truism - nonsensical unless interpreted within a greater context.

And it looks to me that's just what the GP poster was trying to do - challenge others to argue with a truism while pretending that the context in which it was stated isn't relevant.