Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by banana_giraffe 2030 days ago
Huh, right you are. I did a cursory search, but whatever I saw clearly was wrong.

That said, something is going on that I can't explain:

    # Default settings for aws
    $ time aws s3 cp /dev/shm/1GB.bin s3://test-kihaqtowex/a
    upload: ../../dev/shm/1GB.bin to s3://test-kihaqtowex/a

    real    0m10.312s
    user    0m5.909s
    sys     0m4.204s

    $ aws configure set default.s3.max_concurrent_requests 4
    $ time aws s3 cp /dev/shm/1GB.bin s3://test-kihaqtowex/b
    upload: ../../dev/shm/1GB.bin to s3://test-kihaqtowex/b

    real    0m26.732s
    user    0m4.989s
    sys     0m2.741s

    $ time cp /dev/shm/1GB.bin s3fs_mount_-kihaqtowex/c

    real    0m26.368s
    user    0m0.006s
    sys     0m0.699s
(I did multiple runs, though not hundreds so I can't say with certainty this would hold)

I swear the difference was worse in the past, so maybe things have improved. Still not worth the added slowness to me for my use cases.

1 comments

Thanks for testing! You may improve performance via increasing -o parallel_count (default="5"). Newer versions of s3fs have improved performance but please report any cliffs at https://github.com/s3fs-fuse/s3fs-fuse/issues .