Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by stuzenz 2033 days ago
> Am I just wrong here, or understanding something wrong? I swear everyone I talk to on Signal has changed their safety numbers at least once in the last couple years. Should I not talk to them any more until I verify those in person?

I think keybase.io are on to the correct idea here. There was a good blog post about it somewhere in their blog.

It wasn't this one - but this one does talk specifically to the problem you describe.

https://keybase.io/blog/chat-apps-softer-than-tofu

2 comments

Keybase also has the system where you can approve a new device from another. Why can't we have the same thing w/ Signal? Maybe tack on the PIN to make it a bit more secure.
If you backup the Signal data on the old device and restore it on the new one, your safety number won't change. This is the proper way to securely migrate to a new device.
I think that's a serious backdoor for a coercive attacker. They only need access to the original device once and can then assume the identity of the contact on another device.
You might be thinking of this one? https://keybase.io/blog/keybase-new-key-model