Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hirple 2029 days ago
Curious what you prefer about PyCharm over emacs + LSP.

I'm a pretty poor PyCharm power-user, so wondering what I"m missing.
1 comments
simiones 2029 days ago
PyCharm, like most IntelliJ IDEs, has excellent refactoring capabilities, much better than what LSP currently offers.

E.g. extract method, extract class, advanced navigation like "data flow to here" etc

They may not work in extremely dynamic Python code (e.g. they will obviously not work past an `exec`).

link
disgruntledphd2 2028 days ago
This is the biggest flaw in LSP (for Python at least), right now.

How difficult is it to implement basic extract function/method functionality?

I'd be tempted to try doing it, as I would absolutely love to have this in Emacs.

link
hirple 2028 days ago
I'd be happy to help here too, let me know. I can try to hack some elisp together tomorrow.

Looks like rope would be a decent place to start.

link
simiones 2028 days ago
I think some basic extract method has made it into lsp-mode or some enhancement, I have been seeing it for Go at least. That could serve as an inspiration.

I haven't honestly played around with it though to see if it successfully converts local variables to parameters/return values though, which would be the biggest time saver.

link