Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by SV_BubbleTime 2040 days ago
Do you have a fire extinguisher in your home?

Personally. I don’t want to live in a place where people are expecting fire.

A CCW isn’t about “feeling” safe. It’s about recognizing that the police/government might not be able to protect you (and has no duty to) if you need it.

It is your civil right to keep and bear arms. I’m not sure you would buy the your own argument if it was on any other right besides guns.

1 comments

can you kill someone with a fire extinguisher?
It's a little trickier, but yes.
Well, I guess there's no point arguing here : )
1. Yes, absolutely. Multiple ways probably.

2. Stopping is the goal, it’s just that sometimes that means killing... but...

3. Is killing is always wrong? Almost every society and religion has a concept of justified homicide. Sometimes people can act in a way that forfeits their right to walk among us. I don’t accept “guns can kill” is an argument against guns. It’s basically the feature that makes them so desirable for defense. When you have a life or death problem, you are going to call a cop because they will bring a gun. Some of us are skipping that middleman for efficiency.

I’ve made good in my soul that I can take a life if it meant defense of self, family, or other. If you can’t do that, then by all means don’t own a firearm, no one will force you to. We just ask you don’t try and make that decision for us.

But, none of it has to do with “feeling” safe.

Oh boy, you should watch Gaspar Noe’s “Irreversible”.