Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by germinalphrase 2039 days ago
Does no one - by this logic - ever die of AIDS because it’s something else (like pneumonia) that does them in at the end?
1 comments

That’s an interesting question. Officially the answer is “no”, but what if someone with AIDS contracts COVID-19 and dies? Does that person count toward both statistics? How many statistics can one death count towards?

Now try “diabetes and hypertension”, or “lung cancer”, or “temporary immunodeficiency” and you can start to see how dishonest it is to represent the death toll of this disease as a single number, based on an interpretation that generates the largest possible number, and an interpretation not used with any other respiratory disease.

Is it the bullet or the blood loss that kills me?
Again, an interesting question. You will find out that a concept like “death toll” does not fit neatly into linear or trivially-nonlinear equations.