Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Mediterraneo10 2042 days ago
There are however a few vegan activists who oppose lab-grown meat (and things like the Awesome Burger) on the grounds that we will never truly love our animal brothers and sisters and treat them justly, until we have lost the very appetite for meat.
3 comments

They're missing an opportunity. We've had jackfruit for a while now and synthetic meat is nothing new in some sense. This is like policing the aesthetics of the Maillard reaction.

Framing the argument strictly in terms of consumption without inspecting the conditions of production also betrays a wider perspective on how we can achieve ethical or sustainable practices. And certainly it's inimical to the reality that there needs to be reform at the institutional and corporate tier of practice with higher priority rather than castigate individual and cultural consumption.

People who have made a difficult personal sacrifice for their ideals often react poorly to that sacrifice becoming obsolete, and transform the now unnecessary sacrifice into a social marker.

In this case: meat is enjoyable, but eating it is unethical, so I will make the sacrifice not to eat it. If it becomes possible to eat meat while still being ethical, then I still won’t because it marks me as someone who is willing to make a sacrifice to be ethical.

That sounds a little desperate. I 'truly love' few things. I'll give that one a miss.