Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ianmobbs 2045 days ago
I've been following Purism for a month or so, and I love the idea of the Librem 5, but is the phone really going to be worth $2,000?
4 comments

The made-in-USA version is $2,000, but the made-in-China version is $800, so it's only $2,000 if you want your phone to be made in the USA.
What's great is they list the country of origin for each component on the product page of the USA version. Love the transparency. Some of the parts are not from the USA.
Ah missed that, thanks
You aren't buying a phone when you buy the librem 5. You are funding the development of open source phones so there will eventually be a v2 and v3 which are better value for money when the hard work was done in v1.
> You are funding the development of open source phones

You're funding a FOSS operating system and a phone with some security features. We already have dozens of open source mobile OS's, the hardware design is still proprietary. What's really needed is an open source baseband firmware and no one is funding that sadly.

Despite the baseband/cpu isolation I fear it still has a host of vulnerabilities up its sleeve. One AT command away from certain doom (yes that's sarcastic hyperbole with a sliver of truth)

The journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step.
You're also funding the allegedly inefficient supply chain. Too bad I can't find the post about it right now, it was from an ex-purism guy.

Edit: It's the top one of the two linked by pengaru (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25143382 / https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Zlatan-T...).

> Purism seemingly never tried to get better deal and the South San Francisco partner abused this so that is why Purism Librems are double the price they should be.

Only the US-produced version is $2000, and that's an accurate price considering the difficulty of manufacturing an entire phone platform domestically.

The regular version is $799.

Worth is relative. It won't be packed full of 2000$ worth of Android or Apple flagship hardware. But it will cost around 2000$ to deliver this specific product in the manner it's being delivered.
How is the pine phone $200 with only slightly lower specs?
The PinePhone isn't assembled in a US factory, for starters ($2000 refers only to the special "Librem 5 USA" edition with tightened supply chain).
Sure, but 10x is a lot.
Of course. USA assembly is pretty expensive though, it's a low volume product (so the cost of setting up additional factory won't get distributed across many devices) and I'm not aware of any competition there, so the final price is hardly surprising IMO.

The regular version costs "just" 4 times the PinePhone price, but with Librem 5 you get not only more powerful hardware with more expensive components, but also warranty, continued software development and tech support.