Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dingaling 2046 days ago
> Alice should either host her photos on Instagram, or learn how to run letsencrypt.

Both leading to further centralisation of the Internet.

> by providing installers to inject CAs into system cert stores

That's already pointless on Android, user-installed CAs are ignored by default unless an app developer opts in to using them.

Once we go down this path there's no turning back to the user-centric Web of the 1990s / 2000s

1 comments

> That's already pointless on Android, user-installed CAs are ignored by default unless an app developer opts in to using them.

And? App developers should opt in to ignoring transport security. I’m sure a bunch of Android shitware attempts to install CAs either via user interaction or exploitation.

> Once we go down this path there's no turning back to the user-centric Web of the 1990s / 2000s

The landscape we live in now is very different to then. I’m all for a free web, but not at the cost of security. The web is now a multi billion trillion dollar industry. Weakening security just so Bob can see Alices’ holiday pics in situation where Alice can’t figure out letsencrypt, is frankly unhinged.

If you want a ‘free web’ you’re welcome to disable any HTTPS enforcement and disable TLS cert checking entirely. Hell, fork a browser, be very clear about the security weaknesses and publish on github if you feel that strongly, I’ll even star it for you.

The web is now a multi billion trillion dollar industry.

Maybe your web service is, but mine isn't. Mine is a specialized embedded device server that now has an expiration date for no reason on God's green earth.

Feel free to fork Mozilla codebases if you disagree with fundamental security concepts.