Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by unwantedLetters 5534 days ago
For those of us that don't know anything about it, can someone explain the significance of this achievement?
2 comments

From the article:

"The long term storage of significant amounts of antihydrogen should soon settle the question of whether antimatter falls up or down."

One reason they would like to know if antimatter is repelled by gravity is that it could explain why the Universe is expanding at an accelerating rate.[1]

[1]: http://www.physorg.com/news/2011-04-antimatter-gravity-unive...

>>"The long term storage of significant amounts of antihydrogen should soon settle the question of whether antimatter falls up or down."

Would this mean that if I am "holding onto" a chunk of antimatter heaver than myself I will fall up into space?

Well, technically, it wouldn't be possible for a chunk of antimatter to be heavier than you.

But yeah, one theory is that if you hold one that's more massive than you are, its repulsion would overpower your attraction, and bang, zoom, straight to the moon!

it should be repelled by moon's gravity back to earth - recursion... =))
Not unless it's in a tube, and it would quickly reach an equilibrium anyway.
Unless he starts using his legs for extra propulsion!
If you were holding onto a chunk of antimatter you would probably be missing a hand.
1 megaton nuke is about 4000 TeraJoules of energy.

10g of antimatter yields about 10^15 Joules - i.e. 1 PetaJoule, or the equivalent of a 2+ Megaton nuke.

If you were holding onto a chunk of antimatter large enough to hold onto you'd be missing half of London.

Not sure if that conclusion is right. It probably wouldn't result in an explosion and the energy output would probably be in the form of light. Regardless, I'm going with Stephen Hawking on this one: "If you ever meet your anti-self, don't shake hands!"
"It probably wouldn't result in an explosion and the energy output would probably be in the form of light."

That's what nukes do too. Turns out that dumping absurd amounts of light (various parts of the spectrum, but certainly including visible) into the surrounding area absurdly fast tends to fuck stuff up pretty good.

Funny that I actually managed to get the maths wrong. 4000 TeraJoules is 4 PetaJoules, i.e. 10g of antimatter is actually a 0.25 Megaton nuke. Still packs some serious punch, but I totally fail at arithmetic, it seems.
Not if you're holding onto it using a magnetic field, or any other method that doesn't involve direct contact.
Is there any conceivable way to make such a system fail-safe?
Nothing is fail-safe.
The first paragraphs at Wikipedia may help to understand the significance http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antimatter