Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by avenger123 2055 days ago
Having gone from considering weightlifting a simple set of exercises to now understanding the complexity and nuances of it, this is great advice.

I'm not sure how much value there is to just state "Build physical strength" and the main take away is to do deadlifts. I think there isn't any doubt from a health perspective that doing weightlifting has benefits for overall health but the program someone should go on is dependent on so many factors. Also, why can't it just be "Stay physically active". I would say that has further greater benefits than even weightlifting. Doing half an hour to an hour of moderate cardio activity every day or a few times a week is great.

My recommendation for someone wanting to seriously get into weight lifting is to do your research. There is definitely a lot of "bro science" out there but fortunately there is also a great set of resources out there that is firmly in the realm of solid science.

Here is some Youtube channels that are very solid on approaching weightlifting grounded in real practice and science: Jeff Nippard, mountaindog1 (John Meadows), Greg Doucette, VitruvianPhysique and Renaissance Periodization.

A good book is: https://www.amazon.ca/Science-Development-Muscle-Hypertrophy...

What I have personally found is that for me there is two primary focus points: reducing the risk of injury and keeping consistent with the program. Reducing risk of injury comes down to knowing your own limits for what exercises are comfortable and not going hard with attempting to do max reps all the time. Personally, I don't do any traditional squats and for deadlifts I use a trap bar. Being consistent is much harder. Making a schedule to be in the gym three to four times a week is really hard.

So, yeah, if you want to get started with weightlifting, spend a few hours with those Youtube channels. Picking a class of exercises as a one size fits all is definitely not the way to go.

2 comments

> Here is some Youtube channels that are very solid on approaching weightlifting grounded in real practice and science: Jeff Nippard, mountaindog1 (John Meadows), Greg Doucette, VitruvianPhysique and Renaissance Periodization.

I'd add Mark Rippetoe (Starting Strength on Youtube) and Alan Thrall to that list.

I'd also add Jeremy Ethier for the highest production value videos I've comes across, which typically include insights from research in the flow of the video, and which use nice overlay 'explainer graphics,' which make it easier to understand his detailed breakdowns of muscle-targeting, desired motions/angles etc.

Here's an example where he's talking about developing strength to get your first pull-ups: https://youtu.be/3YvfRx31xDE?t=75

Great source for problem solving specific issues that come up in strength training.

I would highly recommend the Athlean-X channel run by Jeff Cavaliere.. He provides first-hand hard-won experiences, rather than only quoting "some studies"..