Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by kspacewalk2 2060 days ago
The biggest issue is this ridiculous heterogeneity.

Canada is no less of a federal country with devolved decision-making powers, perhaps even more so. And yet we have one system of casting and tallying votes, presided over by one federal electoral commission, which reports to the parliament and not to the government. It was set up in 1920 and worked out very well for us, delivering 100 years of bullshit-free elections.

Sometimes countries adopt different laws and you cannot unequivocally say one is better than the other. But sometimes, like here, one way is clearly, unequivocally superior. This is too important to leave to amateur hour and should be done right, Canada's way.

1 comments

Canada doesn't have anything like a President. The Prime Minister is chosen the way the US chooses the Speaker of the House. That's far far more important than the details of the administration of voting.
That's not really important in any way. What's important is the uniformity in the way votes are cast and tallied, and having a single independent federal agency to govern the process.