[JoshTriplett]

> (A) generates income, directly or indirectly, from the collection, processing, sale, or sharing of user data; and

OK, this is substantially better than any other proposal I've seen. It means that any platform that doesn't make money off of user data (e.g. one that makes money in some more ethical way) is exempt.

[tzs]

That seems overly broad. The whole point of a communications service from the user's point of view is to process user data, namely the messages that the user sends or receives via that service.