[pwinnski]

Yes, this is a tiny subset of everything I've downloaded, and includes nothing recent at all.

It might contain everything I've ever double-clicked and been told wasn't safe, but I've long developed a habit of right-clicking and choosing "Open" to bypass that prompt, which seems to also result in no record here.

I'm just guessing, though. I just know this is very wrong: "This will be a list of everything you’ve downloaded on your Mac, regardless of which program you used. The only exception to this is apps from the Mac App Store."