[hknd]

Mobx is not a global state, you can create your stores as granular as you want them to.

Each widget can have a store, each section can have a store, each view can have a store, etc. You decicde what works for you.

(I use mobx in a large and complex trading application)

[shermanmccoy]

The way that mobx is advised to be used, that is/was documented by its author, promotes the usage of a rootStore, which has as members all the various granular store objects. Is this how your organisation's stores are constructed?

[hknd]

We used to have that but moved to an approach with multiple "rootStores" per self-contained route (sometimes we have more than 1 root store in such a scenario).

But we also have multiple smaller stores which are not connected to the root store. Think: multiple not-connected trees where each node is a store.

I must agree that both approaches have pros and cons, e.g. passing down data down a long path of stores is annoying.

[shermanmccoy]

In my experience, not specific to front end, managing multiple long life objects can be a headache.

Out of curiosity, how do your 'not connected' stores know when, say, a user logs out?

Also, I suppose you have to write code, bespoke to each object, to be able to reset these objects too?

[cloverich]

(Thinking in terms of local stores)

> how do your 'not connected' stores know when, say, a user logs out?

If they need this information, it can be passed in from above, or pulled from context. But unless the store and component need to stay mounted when user logs out, they might not need to do anything. There's nothing wrong with a local store being created by a component that receives props and provides them via constructor arguments.

> write code, bespoke to each object, to be able to reset these objects too?

I almost never do this, and nearly always create a new store when the component mounts. The combination of `useLocalStore`[1] with mobx-react-lite makes this straight forward. So per the above example, your component could `useLocalObservable(() => new Store(props.user))`

[1]: https://mobx.js.org/react-integration.html

[shermanmccoy]

To be honest I don't understand why people use mobx this way. I mean short life store objects, populated by props, that are recreated every mount. Might as well just use React state and save the overhead. You might say, because I have several components using the same business logic and fields and such, I can inject the same store into multiple components. I would say that logic can go in functions which take React state as their argument. You don't need a global state management tool to separate business logic from the view.

[cloverich]

> Might as well just use React state and save the overhead. Unless you mean conceptual overhead (i.e another library), it should be less overhead with mobx because there's no need to re-create objects on every re-render, and further re-renders in general are less common (since mobx precisely controls renders for you). Also localStore's need not be short lived by definition, just local. I have a notes app where the main components localStore stays mounted for (literally) days :)

[hknd]

Most of the stores not long-life objects.

The current store holding most of the displayed data stays alive (while not switching to a different route), but everything else resets or gets recreated when needed. (no need to keep stores alive if they are not required or used)

Stores for specific "sub" views (think dialogs, tabs, collapsibles, ...) are getting created/destroyed ad-hoc.

Main Store for a specific view holds the current data (which receives updates via gql subscriptions ~every second), the current filter which is applied to it's children (only show Apple related securities) and currently visible/hidden state of any children.

User/App/Global related attributes which don't change often are stored in a globally available object (and is easy for us as users don't log out or anything)

[nsonha]

no, do you have source for that? Mobx is built on the concept of atom which you can put anywhere in your app, be it a module, a context or a component.

[shermanmccoy]

https://mobx.js.org/defining-data-stores.html#combining-mult...