Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by throwaway8941 2083 days ago
This does not answer your question, but wouldn't it be easier to get a cheap UPS with enough battery life to get your machine through additional 5 minutes of uptime?

Although I've had problems with hardware hanging so completely that it does not respond to the reset button, and the only option is to cut power, so UPS does not provide full protection.
1 comments
smolder 2082 days ago
UPSs are never really cheap, since when converting AC to DC to AC you lose a significant amount of power efficiency for your equipment. The funny part is the server PSU then converts back to DC power yet again. My understanding is that well optimized data centers distribute conditioned, battery backed DC power directly to devices to avoid those double conversion losses.
link
zrm 2082 days ago
A small UPS will often have the equipment running directly on AC input power and only switch to the battery if the input power fails.
link
smolder 2082 days ago
Oh, thanks for the correction. It seems I forgot that type existed or just never knew. Now I'm curious about the relative merits. I'd guess the transition is not as smooth and presents some kind of a risk that's unacceptable for critical infra.
link
agapon 2082 days ago
The terms that describe those types are Line-interactive and On-line UPS.

E.g., https://blog.tripplite.com/line-interactive-vs-on-line-ups-s...

link
tuatoru 2082 days ago
It'd be good if consumer UPSes had DC output for this reason. If only laptops could be standardized in terms of voltage requirements.

A lot of them are pretty similar; 19V - 21V seems quite common.

Until recently phones were standardized on 5V. Now, it's a mess again. :-(

link
smolder 2081 days ago
I vaguely recall seeing someone modify their UPS for this in their "homelab", such that they were running a 12v cable modem, router and WAP off of the UPS battery pack directly somehow. They had dramatically longer run time from a full charge. (Well more than double, I think.)
link
yencabulator 2081 days ago
Ooh, imagine a NUC or such small enough machine running off of USB-C Power Delivery. 65 Watt power budget easily. I guess a Raspberry Pi would count as that?

Then a battery pack could provide that, as DC.

link