Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by whatshisface 2093 days ago
Why would someone in Bach's era needed to have recognized him as a world-class composer? If his music appealed to them personally they would know, and if they were a "record label," the fact that it wasn't popular at the time is all they would need to know.
1 comments

My point was that Bach accomplished more than just about any composer before or since.

Some people put Mozart and Beethoven up there (I think he was better at his best and I believe more prolific generally, but YMMV).

The point is, though, that almost no one in history has rivaled Bach for his compositional feats, yet it took a hundred years after his death before people really started to realize that.

If that was true for him, I question whether it's realistic to count on human ability to recognize accomplishments as a useful metric.