Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by wormslayer666 2088 days ago
Direct link to one of the early adopter wikis: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikip%C3%A9dia:Accueil_princip...
5 comments

From that link, it seems like the change in the text column width behavior, which is promoted as limiting text columns to a maximum width, in practice creates a min-width as well which can be quite wide. That is, in the old wikipedia, you can adjust the browser window to make the text column arbitrarily narrow, but in the new wikipedia — depending on other elements on the screen — in practice can you from having an uncomfortably wide column of text that you can't adjust to be any narrower.

So it seems like kind of a mixed bag readability-wise.

edit: For example, this article's main text area seems to have a width of around 155 characters, while typography rules of thumb dictate not exceeding 75 or so:

https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reichsgau_Wartheland

And the sidebar works with no JS. Perfect!
There could be other factors involved, but it takes longer for fr.wikipedia.org to load on my computer than en.wikipedia.org. I hope Wikipedia will remain usable on old and slow devices.
Quite a pleasant change
Cool, instead of having Wikipedia zoomed in to 150% I have to have this one zoomed at 170%.
Why? They both use the same font size and line height.