Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hal9000-tng 2098 days ago
You are replying to a point that the GP didn't make. This was the precursor for the might-as-well-go-for-letsencrypt statement:

"What if they can register a very similar / regional domain that you didn’t set up already?"

In other words, they register fakebook.com and then just go get a TLS cert for it. If you're not looking carefully, you might not notice the difference.

Whether the CA system, with fungible, interchangeable certificates that can be issued by dozens of CA's (pinning excepted), is worth sinking lots of trust into is an entirely different matter ;)
1 comments
tialaramex 2098 days ago
The Web PKI does a pretty good job of making the web browser do what lay people assume it did anyway. Surely this is news.ycombinator.com or else why does it says so in the URL bar? Without the Web PKI there was no assurance of that whatsoever, which is not intuitively obvious.

But a very similar domain is the wrong domain. This is not a great novelty, people are aware that a ROJEX watch isn't the real deal, no surprise Fakebook isn't the social media site you actually wanted either.

In terms of authentication, this is where WebAuthn shines because it's tied to that actual domain name. Even if you're 100% dead certain this is really Facebook, your WebAuthn authenticator can't help you. There is no "Look, I know the URL says Fakebook, but ignore that, I am 100% sure this is really Facebook, just shut up and take my money" button.

link
headmelted 2098 days ago
So my point was that having news.ycombimator.com in the title and address bar is not going to flag anything if they both match and have a SSL cert that's been signed by an authority.

Probably more relevant is that if I have registered luxowatch.com to sell my lovely watches, but am a small store, I certainly won't have registered (as yet) a bunch of global domains. There's nothing stopping you registering luxowatch.co.uk or luxowatch.net with a valid SSL cert to scam my potential customers. Cloning my site to one of those domains (with cert) can be done almost instantly for close to zero cost.

link