Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by yes_man 2109 days ago
I am just another armchair physicist but saying there is no detection of dark matter sounds a bit like circular reasoning. You detect matter like your phone in your hand through electromagnetic interaction. We have detected that there is something in space that completely disregards electromagnetic force, but exerts gravitational force. Hence the idea that we have not detected it is simultaneously false in 2 ways:

- it cannot be detected the way you detect your phone in your hand or see light so your definition of detection seems to escape the basic premise of dark matter: its ability to avoid electromagnetic force, and also,

- we have detected it through gravitational anomalies

1 comments

But to be fair, you can detect the phone in your hands many many many ways.

With the DM effect, we ONLY see gravitational anomalies as you said. Though DM may very well be the reason, it does not automatically mean it MUST be some matter we cannot see