Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by et-al 2114 days ago
Leaving a perfectly fine RAV4 and attempting to hoof 13 miles to another car is a really poor decision.
2 comments

You should actually check a map before being so contemptuously judgemental. This ain't suburbia where you can just always find another route to drive out: https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Devils+Postpile+National+Mon...

The RAV4 was parked at a dead end trailhead. The route out was directly through the area the fire was rapidly overtaking. They got conflicting information about the status of the road. They drove as far as seemed reasonable to them based on the information they had, then changed plans when it appeared to them they were cut off. I'd emphasize they were pretty accurate in that call btw. They left the RAV4 about 8 miles north of where people had to shelter in a freaking lake until chinook helicopters could rescue them.

They did not know for certain that the route out with the RAV4 was a dead end. And the folks who were going in the opposite direction, with arguably better local information, ended up not having to shelter in a "freaking lake".

> We then learned many of the people we passed in caravans had made it out thanks to the National Forest Service and Local Officials guiding them through the scene.

Admittedly it's easy to armchair-quarterback this in hindset, but going from the known to the unknown is generally a bad idea. And there were plenty of unknown unknowns back to the other car if you wanna pull Rumsfeld into this.

The information we had to go on was

1) a single lat/lon coordinate of the fire about 2 mi from the road

2) the plume of smoke suggesting the fire was many miles side

3) cars racing both towards and away from the fire

4) rumors that people were trapped somewhere ahead

5) advice from a ranger that hiking to Red’s Meadow should be safe