Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nobodyshere 2127 days ago
Unlike some competitors, Nitrokey contains a complete and standard compliant USB plug. This ensures thousands of insertions without connectivity issues.

Here I am waiting for a Type-C from them. Yet they claim that’s a good thing. What utter bullshit.

3 comments

I don't think Nitrokey is claiming that the lack of USB Type-C connector is a good thing. Rather, it appears to be a specific reference to Yubikey's (and maybe also other competitors') "half USB" designs where the very slim HSM slides into a USB port, but isn't actually a USB-compliant connector.

Take a look at https://www.yubico.com/product/yubikey-5-nano for an example.

I think both approaches are fine, and it's really a matter of preference. But it _would_ be nice if manufacturers of USB-connected devices that strictly speaking aren't actually USB-compliant would be a little more explicit about that detail.

USB-C plug would still be complete and standard compliant USB (but not USB-A) plug.
Yep. Also way more convenient to connect to modern android smartphones.
YubiKey and SoloKey allow a choice between USB-A and USB-C. You can also an adapter for either. Quite handy to have one of such anyway.
I’ve also begun using trezor for the same purpose and from security standpoint it is even better. Onscreen pin code is required and a tap on the screen with the exact info on what service is trying to log in.